Anything wrong with this?

[Dan]

Would you have done anything different in this?

 

[White Room]

I would have made the cuts in the corner the same width....

 

[Dan]

Think you could have got the mosaic joint match the tile joint?

 

[White Room]

True but the cuts at the bottom of the mosaic would have been slithers, the field tile could have been raised up.

Depends on the rest of the room though if it continued all the way round.

 

[Old Mod]

I would have made the cuts in the corner the same width....

Marks definitely right there!
I think it looks out of proportion too.
For me the feature shouldn't be bigger than the field tile within the shower. It should be a feature or the whole cubicle, this is neither one or the other.
If they're 50x50 mosaic then they make up 2/3rds of a 900 tray, I'd of suggested reducing the size of the feature, but that's a completely subjective issue.
But at the very least centre them to the tray properly.
I think the bonding of the joints is also personal taste, I don't mind seeing the joints bond through or miss, as long as they fall in the middle, but again this neither one or the other.
When it comes to details like this I always involve the client, show them their options and come to an agreement first.
Has the band of mosaic on the right been positioned that way because of the wand outlet, has he tried to get it centre of the four mosaic?

Think you could have got the mosaic joint match the tile joint?

They look like complimentary mosaic to the field tile so they should line up, and if they are slightly out there's generally no reason the mosaic can't be open or closed to suit.

Then it may have taken me up to a day longer because of all the adjustments, but if it was my job and u were the client Dan, u wouldn't even be asking that question!

But I'm sure u can make another thread about that Dan.

 

[Alan.P]

Yeah, to much feature, tile cuts to the corner and line the joints. all easy to say without seeing the whole job of course

 

[Lee@emctiles]

over done it on the feature walls IMHO

 

[Dan]

I'm guessing it's two sheets wide. Perhaps should have been one sheet wide? Or even less?

 

[widler]

Defo made the corner the same widths, probably reduced the mosaics though as well.
The joints don't bother me 1 bit, most of the time the mosaics are that far out of skew with each other it looks better off line if u know what i mean

 

[Dan]

 

[Old Mod]

I'm guessing it's two sheets wide. Perhaps should have been one sheet wide? Or even less?

Errrrrm...... Who's work have u got us critiquing?
Is it a member!

 

[Dan]

He is a member yeah. I wont link to his profile he didn't ask for this. I'm not having a dig either. I said to him that I'd have moved the mosaic tiles up or down to get them to match the grout lines. He said they're 1mm out so it'd have gone off line anyway. I said with mosaics you can usually deal with 1mm.

Anyway, turns out he's done alright IMO. And it seems it's personal preference. And the customer loved it. So that's the main thing.

Don't think he's an active member but he is one.

 

[Old Mod]

He is a member yeah. I wont link to his profile he didn't ask for this. I'm not having a dig either. I said to him that I'd have moved the mosaic tiles up or down to get them to match the grout lines. He said they're 1mm out so it'd have gone off line anyway. I said with mosaics you can usually deal with 1mm.

Anyway, turns out he's done alright IMO. And it seems it's personal preference. And the customer loved it. So that's the main thing.

Don't think he's an active member but he is one.

Uh huh! Haha
Long as the client is happy, all that matters!

 

[p4ulo]

Doesn't it look better when you see it in context.
It all kinda makes sense then, although it would have been fairly easy to knock a "column" or two of mosaic off to get the same size tile at both sides.