History lessson needed from skilled Shower Installers !!!

[White Room]

Thats right Marc, experience does'nt seem to count for anything but a shed load of qualifications does....

 

[Perry]

I have been a expert witness in a court case for someone that came on here and was treated as one by the judge. And my report was the sole reason for winning the case.

 

[The D]

i have not read the full thread but tiling on to ply is not good having said that the definition of tiling is to provide a water proof and reasonably flat surface covering.

 

[Cottage lady]

Thank you Gary

This was all I was asking really .... certainly not seeking any legal advice here !
I am grateful for all the opinions received .... my thanks to you all.

 

[Old Mod]

This was all I was asking really .... certainly not seeking any legal advice here !
I am grateful for all the opinions received .... my thanks to you all.

It wasn't suggested that you were seeking legal advice at all, as well you know! My objection is in which manor you chose to gather your information! You been ambiguous at best with the information supplied in the hope, it would certainly appear, to help you take action against another party! Personally for me that is an insult to my intelligence and underhand! It appears from MY perspective that you asking us to help you bring a case against some work carried out some 6-7yrs ago without relaying all the relevant information so that we can decide for ourselves whether or not it is in fact poor workmanship! Apart from the fact that you could have suffered an earthquake in your area causing subsidence in your surrounding district! Excessive example? Yes of course! But it relays my objection to this method of gleaning information. Perhaps if you had been upfront with your problem initially it wouldn't have attracted such a cynical view from some members! And I know for sure you would have collected the information you required without alienating decent members of a forum who do their level best to help!

 

[Deleted member 9966]

Tanking kits were certainly available in 2009/2010 when I refurbished my en-suite shower room, and from what I recall, these kits and other water repelling boards like Wedi and Hardie were available quite readily if you knew where to find them and what you were looking for, and had been around for some time.

My best suggestion would be to contact Mapei who do a paint-on type tanking kit, as well as a wallpaper type roll kit, and perhaps Wedi and James Hardie and ask them exactly when their tanking products hit the shelves in the UK.

But it does all come down to knowing that these products were around back then, and that your installer knew what they were and the merits of having them.

I had a paint-on kit for my shower room because the house-builder had done a particularly poor job at installing the shower area and frequently I ended up with puddles of water in the lounge below. Once bitten, twice shy.

 

[IHB]

I think even if a tanking kit was available at the time it doesn't mean that the tiler was wrong not to use one. I'm sure there are common practices now that will be frowned upon in 10 years time. You can't use hindsight to work out which of the 100s of new products/practices will catch on and become the new standard.

If the tiler claimed to be working to a British Standard and if the BS said tanking was necessary (I'm not sure it did) then you might be able to claim that the work hadn't been completed as paid for. Otherwise I'd say that there's no chance of a claim.

 

[Colour Republic]

It wasn't suggested that you were seeking legal advice at all, as well you know! My objection is in which manor you chose to gather your information! You been ambiguous at best with the information supplied in the hope, it would certainly appear, to help you take action against another party! Personally for me that is an insult to my intelligence and underhand! It appears from MY perspective that you asking us to help you bring a case against some work carried out some 6-7yrs ago without relaying all the relevant information so that we can decide for ourselves whether or not it is in fact poor workmanship! Apart from the fact that you could have suffered an earthquake in your area causing subsidence in your surrounding district! Excessive example? Yes of course! But it relays my objection to this method of gleaning information. Perhaps if you had been upfront with your problem initially it wouldn't have attracted such a cynical view from some members! And I know for sure you would have collected the information you required without alienating decent members of a forum who do their level best to help!

Well said sir!

 

[AliGage]

All i could say has been said.
It does look as though we are preparing for a legal battle here. In which case, im out.
Dont think any part of this thread will be black and white.
My gut tells me that 7 years down the line we probably arent investigating an out and out cowboy.
Minefield!

 

[Chalker]

In the great words of Duncan Bannatyne.... I'm oot!

 

[Perry]

The question is yes tanking was about in 2007. But would you be able to win a court case no.

 

[Brian the Tile]

Cant believe some folk I really cant