Butech anticracking anti fracture mat - experience?

[J Sid]

Lots of questions asked, will be interesting to see what the answers will be

 

[Dumbo]

If I was the tiler I would now be doing a test on this . Probably sandwiching a piece between two tiles leave for a couple of days then try and separate .

 

[triode]

Was your screed moisture tested?
that’s a large area, what type of screed is it please?

Sand and cement screed with reinforcing fibres, I'm told. It was not moisture tested but the adhesive seems well bonded to it.
Thanks.
[automerge]1571237440[/automerge]

A picture showing the back of a lifted tile and also the membrane where it came from , this would be informative .

Have attached picture with back of a lifted tile.

 

[Dumbo]

I would like to see the membrane both sides and the floor where it was removed please .

 

[triode]

I would like to see the membrane both sides and the floor where it was removed please .

Don't know how well these images come across. Very grateful for all the input/comments here. Thanks.
Chris

 

[Dumbo]

I would have to check but I think. Wrong size trowel for membrane to floor and not bedded in properly . Maybe adhesive a bit dry , see photo .
Also from picture of tile I think looking at tile edges it appears adhesive was applied to tile and not floor and that is why the bond is weak there

 

[triode]

I would have to check but I think. Wrong size trowel for membrane to floor and not bedded in properly . Maybe adhesive a bit dry , see photo .
Also from picture of tile I think looking at tile edges it appears adhesive was applied to tile and not floor and that is why the bond is weak there View attachment 110489

Thanks, yes I noticed these areas in adhesive between screed and membrane that are not flattened and still ridged or notched. I was not around when tiles laid - are you saying the correct technique is to out adhesive on both back of tile and direct onto membrane before sticking it down?
Thanks,
Chris

 

[Dumbo]

You should spread adhesive onto membrane and back butter the tile at the least

 

[Dumbo]

Now I've just looked at the video and it would appear that tile was stuck well enough to the mat to make the mat delaminated from itself . So really not sure . I would test the mat .

 

[Dumbo]

May be lack of technique isn't the reason for failure but because of this you would struggle to prove to a manufacturer that their system is faulty . I would stick a patch to the floor properly , stick a tile on top using the correct technique including collapsing the ridges , leave it for a couple of days if using rapid set then lift the tile and see what happens. Also maybe do another at the same time just in case it needs to be left longer.