O
Old Mod
If the tiler you're thinking of using is competent enough to realise the weight issues surrounding substrates, there's a fair chance he knows what he's doing. Weight limits are one of the lesser known areas of our industry.
As far as your tile choice for downstairs is concerned, personally I don't know the product, and so far in to the thread as we are, you are reducing the chances of someone who does, seeing your choice. If a thread holds no interest to someone, they tend to stop revisiting quickly.
Maybe start a fresh thread concerned only with the tile choice, but it's not guaranteed you'll find someone who knows it.
As a very general rule of thumb, if the manufacturers guidelines fit your requirement and they are installed correctly, then they should be ok.
But we all understand the concept, 'you get what you pay for!'
Ultimately the choice is yours.
As far as your tile choice for downstairs is concerned, personally I don't know the product, and so far in to the thread as we are, you are reducing the chances of someone who does, seeing your choice. If a thread holds no interest to someone, they tend to stop revisiting quickly.
Maybe start a fresh thread concerned only with the tile choice, but it's not guaranteed you'll find someone who knows it.
As a very general rule of thumb, if the manufacturers guidelines fit your requirement and they are installed correctly, then they should be ok.
But we all understand the concept, 'you get what you pay for!'
Ultimately the choice is yours.