Engineer? Haha
I suffer the same fate!
The depth of the clips at the base are 5mm?
So you need a clearance of 5mm beneath the tile to fit them?
Just want to be clear.
If that's the case, I'd guess at more adhesive, not less.
When using a 10mm notched trowel and you rock the tile back and forth to break the ribs and completely bed the tile, with the compression of the adhesive this gives an average depth of 3mm.
So in effect, your light of adhesive through the centre, so when the adhesive dries, because you don't have a solid 5mm it's sucking the tile back into the wall.
Most quality levelling straps have a maximum depth of about 2mm at the base, allowing them to easily fit beneath the tile.
5mm is massive imo.
Well this is my best guess at the problem. haha
Never experienced it myself, to my knowledge anyway.
Another member may look later and tell me I'm talking cods wallop! Haha
But one thing is for sure, the more solid the base of adhesive, the less chance you have of it shrinking back and pulling the tile with it.
When the adhesive looses its moisture, crystals are formed, effectively mechanically fixing it to the tile.
It's a very strong bond.
So if you have voids beneath, it can pull the tile in to this void.
And if your tiles are effectively suspended around the outside then I'd imagine this is what is sucking the tile in.
But as I say, this all conjecture, because I'm not actually 100%
But it sounds feasible to me at least.
Oh and easiest way to distinguish porcelain from ceramic is to put your tongue on the back of it. 😕😱
If it sticks, it's ceramic, if not, porcelain. Haha