Just spoke to a friend who lays vinyl floor and he also says the Karndean and Amtico have been known to fail as the heat melts the glue on occasions so I've a risk either way.
Considering my floor construction and not wanting to raise the floor level, I wanted to install the UFH between the joists.
The decision to use this mix was made after several UFH suppliers confirmed that this system was the best U-Value compared to the metal trays which are already routed out for pipework and was the only other offered by my supplier without raising floor levels.
UFH companies don't really push this system as they'd rather you bought the products but trust me it works so far & I'm sure the tiles will warm. The system so far has been on for months now. It is nice and warm underfoot.
I have already finished the bathroom and in fairness, the tiles are not warm to touch before the room is up to temp, but that is a small room and heats easily. My kitchen may well require a higher heat.
Do as bri says take the ply board up and use a decent tile backer board laid in flex adhesive and screwed down then a uncoupling membrane on top should be fine to tile I use nicobond matting as I find it fairly thin and easier to use
Do as bri says take the ply board up and use a decent tile backer board laid in flex adhesive and screwed down then a uncoupling membrane on top should be fine to tile I use nicobond matting as I find it fairly thin and easier to use
Backer board won't expand and contract like the ply with the heat from the floor, plus, it's stuck to the substrate as well as screwed adding a little more in the way of rigidity (hardie will tell you it adds no strength but, those who use it know that it does [emoji106]) here's a couple of pics of an identical arrangement to yours except the tiles are limestone
I buy it direct from nicobond I just prefer it over other membranes but I don't want to start a debate on it with others please I know what your all like !!!