Weight of Limestone & Travertine per square meter?

[des511]

Now I am scared:36:

 

[grumpygrouter]

Now I am scared:36:

Wasn't meaning to scare you Des. Weight limits are specified for a reason. Me, as a professional tiler, would not do for a customer what you are looking to do for yourself. It would have serious reprocussions for me insurance wise if anything went wrong.

Going back to my original advise, and bear in mind I don't know what exactly would be involved, I would rip out the skimmed board and put up new stuff. This would pretty much eliminate any weight issues and be safe. if you are going for really heavy stuff, then consider re-boarding with backerboard instead. Screw this to your studs and you can fix up to 50kg/m2.

You always have the option of changing your tiles to small thin ceramics, these will be fine on your skimmed board.

 

[The D]

White star was the only tubbed stuff I used. As for the question by the original poster, I wouldn't use it on stone, therefore my responses were in relation to using bagged stuff. The general concensus on the forums by much more experienced tilers than me is that you will only get 4 to 5m2 out of a 20kg bag of powder.

As the poster was questioning the max weight of skimmed plasterboard and was wanting to fix travertine, I quite rightly stated that with the adhesive and grout, he would be exceeding the maximum safe limits for that substrate and he needs to think again.

You obviously have a different opinion and that is fine. However, even with your own figures, 3kg of white star per m2 plus his 18kg for tiles still exceeds the safe limits for skimmed plasterboard, not allowing for the additional weight of the grout. If he decides to follow your advice that is his choice but personally if it was my children sat in the bath with the possibility of 25 or 30kgs of tile falling on them because I had ignored valid, correct advice I would be mortified.

BAL white star is suitable for fixing natural stone and there is nothing wrong with dispersion adhesives.

 

[Hardibacker Rep]

rip out the plasterboard.....put in Hardibacker...the whole problem go's away!!

:yes:

 

[The D]

If the tiles are only 18 kg there is no problem

 

[grumpygrouter]

BAL white star is suitable for fixing natural stone and there is nothing wrong with dispersion adhesives.

You are absolutely right, White Star will fix natural stone and there is nothing wrong with dispersion adhesives.

Trouble is with dispersion adhesives, they stick by having the moisture absorbed then evaporated away. With a susbtance like limestone or trav, this moisture goes into the tile and then has the possibility of staining the product or bleeding through, giving a not very nice appearance. There are products available that will reduce this bleed and staining problem but they are powdered stuff

Having done my last job of 17m2 of a bathroom with white star, I decided then that it would be the last time I used dispersion adhesive. White Star in particular is a pain to get of tools and the surface of the tiles, but it does stick just about anything.

 

[Hardibacker Rep]

If the tiles are only 18 kg there is no problem

in regard to the weight i guess but would'nt you rather have the back up of another 18kg weight support instead of 2kg????

Your plasterboarding a shower? When (and I mean when!) the water gets behind the tile its going to degrade the bond...make the paper face of the plasteboard go mouldy....making your grout go that lovely shade of green/black.....mould cant grow on cement!

 

[grumpygrouter]

If the tiles are only 18 kg there is no problem

Why is that then? I am not trying to be argumentative, I am just trying to understand why you think there is not a problem?

 

[des511]

The 3 walls that I am Iooking to tile regarding dimensions are
Wall 1 1.8M x 2.1M
Wall 2 1.6M x 2.1M
Wall 2 0.8M x 2.1M

but as you say the problem is not the size of the wall but the strenght of the skim on the plasterboard. The weird thing is that if I would not have come across this forum I would have never thought about the weight issue and would without a second thought put the tiles on the walls.
It makes you think that how many people have done it.
Looks like I will have a busy weekend ahead of me as I have to make up my mind by Monday about what to use. The bathrom will have a bath and not a shower.

Thanks again.

 

[grumpygrouter]

The 3 walls that I am Iooking to tile regarding dimensions are
Wall 1 1.8M x 2.1M
Wall 2 1.6M x 2.1M
Wall 2 0.8M x 2.1M

but as you say the problem is not the size of the wall but the strenght of the skim on the plasterboard. The weird thing is that if I would not have come across this forum I would have never thought about the weight issue and would without a second thought put the tiles on the walls.
It makes you think that how many people have done it.
Looks like I will have a busy weekend ahead of me as I have to make up my mind by Monday about what to use.

Thanks again.

No problems Des. Good luck which every way you decide to go. Maybe drop us a couple of pics when it's done eh.